Those rumours were to put it politely, generally shite. The running order and what they actually sung:
1. Michael Johns - Go Your Own Way (the dreaded 'first to sing' spot!)
2. Jason Castro - I Just Want To Be Your Everything
3. Luke Menard - Killer Queen
4. Robbie Carrico - Hot Blooded
5. Danny Noriega - Until You Come Back To Me
6. David Hernandez - Pap Was A Rolling Stone
7. Jason Yaeger - Long Train Runnin'
8. Chikezie Eze - I Believe
9. David Cook - Alright Now
10. David Archuleta - Imagine
Reality TV Magazine think that Jason Yeager is doomed whilst Chikezie Eze and David Hernandez did more than enough to survive.